Ad Networks a Thing of the Past?

Today I read with one part joy and one part sadness the MediaWeek article titled “ESPN Turns Off Ad Nets to Protect Brand, Content”. The joy is very obvious here at Media Two: Stripping the ad networks of some of the larger sites will now “un-muddy” the waters with the placements and only interactive firms with the best capabilities and know-how will now be equipped to handle strategic online media buys (that was a much longer sentence than what I saw in my mind). Some of the advantages that come from bypassing networks include:

• Knowing that your ads aren’t appearing repeatedly on the same site when you buy more than one ad network. The top two networks make up something like 170% market penetration, and yes, we currently buy on both of them – and no, we don’t ALWAYS know if our ads are appearing on the same page at the same time.
• Traditional agencies that are trying to make a splash into interactive will now have to completely jump in instead of just dipping their toes in the water. Part of the problem we have right now is trying to explain interactive to new clients who have had other agencies do a half-ass job with their campaign.
• Optimization can be brought back in house instead of waiting for the networks “super secret optimization tools”.
• Buying direct always gives you better placements and rapport with the publishers themselves, therefore, hopefully allowing for better brand and position control – and always opening the door for more creative placements that can help advance the industry.
• If a network lowers your campaign exposure because a larger opportunity comes along, it doesn’t force you to frantically find replacement buys.

But with the good, comes the bad…

• Large sites like ESPN are probably going to ask for top dollar, when the networks have already proved we shouldn’t pay that much for them on a straight banner placement.
• Your buying clout and testing capabilities pretty much goes out the door. Has anyone else noticed that there’s no such thing as buying clout online anymore? Not to date myself too much, but I remember the days of placing ads in traditional mediums and the sales reps were willing to give me better rates for my Joe Blow client because they knew that we also worked with Gateway, Bose and others… But I digress.
• If we do want to ramp up our buys in categories we’ve found successful, we can no longer do it as quickly as the one call to the networks.
• More paperwork! You now have to contact 500 sites with orders that you could have gotten previously with just one IO.

Trust me, there’s a lot of good and bad to both routes, but I really think that the more the publishers take back control of their “A” Inventory, the more it will help interactive shops such as ourselves differentiate from the newbies in the industry.