Creative IS Media

Lately I’ve been reading articles about media firms that are starting to break into the creative ranks, but are getting push back from their parent companies or holding companies as they don’t want the media group to compete with their other brand agencies. I “get” that from a holding company strategy. They want to make sure they’re not stepping on each other’s toes, and strategically it opens doors for them if they have a wider array of specialties. However, if I’m the media shops client – I’d be damn sure to push back on them, and here’s why.

For years we have been saying give us more solid clients that understand marketing principles, and we’ll deliver them results – whether it’s brand exposure or ROI – we’re going to produce IF… If the Media Buy is flexible, can be tracked and has good creative execution. Notice I didn’t say “great” creative execution – I only said “good”. If you give us “great” that’s a whole new meaning that we can deliver the world on your doorstep.

To prove our point, we have a client who we had been begging for some brand identity guidelines from. This is not a small client, they just happened to be evolving their brand to keep pace with the fast moving interactive audiences. But when it never came, it was misconstrued by them as saying Media Two didn’t want to create their ads. On the contrary – we were creating very good ads, but our objectives were direct response and that meant there was not a lot of consistency from ad to ad or from site to site. So when the brand guidelines came, they turned the creative chores over to another agency to produce. We immediately saw a negative impact of the new ads and asked for new ones. Three to Four weeks later we had more underperforming ads to the tune of a 150% increase on our CPA. This is not the fault of this new agency, instead it was the result of removing creative from the hands of the media department. With media sitting next to creative on a day-to-day basis and sharing in the experience, you get the benefits of:

• Hearing what new sites are working from media allows design to customize banners (for example – if it’s a sporty site, make an athletic image/message).
• If the media buyer is on the phone and has a value-added opportunity in a new ad size format, the creative group can have that format done in minutes so as to not miss the opportunity.
• If messaging completely bombs – the media buyer will be the first one asking for new ads from creative before the client has even reviewed the end of day numbers.
• Media can keep in check design… By that I mean, every designer wants to create the coolest ads in the world – but when running ads on Yahoo.com or other large sites, you’re limited to 25k file sizes and 15 seconds of animation. If design understands media’s pain – it’s a much happier relationship.

Again – there are a lot of reasons to keep media and design together, and there are a lot of best practices, but I think the biggest reason any of our clients could ever see is that 150% increase on our CPA. As a side note – we have received those creative duties back from the client and are awaiting approval on our first batch of banners under the new brand guidelines. Anyone else smell a case study coming?